WATCH OUT - FAKE RECHARGEABLE BATTERIES
more information to come. detailed report still in progress
F.A.Q.
Q: What makes a rechargeable battery 'FAKE'?
A: A rechargeable battery is fake when the capacity value (expressed in mAh) printed on the battery is greater then the actual capacity of the battery
Q: Will a fake rechargeable battery still work?
A: In most cases a fake rechargeable battery will still work with limited performance, shorter battery life and require to be recharged more frequently.
Q: How will a lower battery capacity affect me?
A: A lower battery capacity will result in less usable power being delivered from a battery. A 2000mAh battery will generally last twice as long as a 1000mAh battery. High current devices such as remote control cars may experience significant performance loss.
Q: How can I avoid buying a fake rechargeable battery?
A: It is hard to find a fake underrated rechargeable battery without testing it. However, if the price is cheap then you are probably not receiving a quality item that will have the capacity that is stated on the package.
Q: How can I test if my batteries are fake / have an underrated capacity?
A: You can use a quality battery charger that performs a charge / discharge cycle following the IEC standard to determine the true capacity of your battery.
Q: How is battery capacity measured?
A: Battery capacity is a product of current delivered by the battery by the duration (in hours) that the current was supplied for. Note that most stated battery capacities are for a duration of 10Hrs. Therefore a 1000mAh battery can deliver 100mA constantly for 10Hrs.
Report Summary
Mid 2009 I purchased a mix of BTY branded NiMH AA & AAA batteries from eBay seller mostwantedauction <- DO NOT BUY FROM THIS SELLER
The BTY AAA batteries were labelled as having a capacity of 1000mAh
The BTY AA batteries were labelled as having a capacity of 2500mAh
The BTY AAA batteries were tested and found to have an average capacity of 300mAh, which is only 30% of the claimed capacity.
The BTY AA batteries were tested and found to have an average capacity of 900mAh, which is only 36% of the claimed capacity of 2500mAh
As a comparison, I also tested some old energizer NiMH AA rechargeable batteries that I have had in use for some 6yrs.
The Energizer AA batteries were labelled as having a capacity of 1850mAh
The Energizer AA batteries were tested and found to have an average capacity of 1570mAh, which is 85% of the claimed capacity of 1850mAh (keep in mind that these batteries have been is use for approx 6years!)
All battery tests were performed with the use of a POWEREX MAHA MH-C9000 Charger-Analyzer.
Each test followed the IEC standard of charging the each battery independently at 0.1C, then discharging at 0.1C to determine the batteries true capacity.
I highly recommend the use of the charger for anyone who uses NiMH rechargeable batteries frequently. It is a useful tool for determining the health of your batteries and eliminating poor performing batteries.
Detailed Report
more information to come. detailed report still in progress
Free counters provided by Vendio.
This site was designed and is managed by Sebastian Najnert
This page was last revised on Sunday, 19 July 2009
|
